Contact between a silica glass lens and silicone rubber is experimentally investigated by simultaneously measuring displacement, force and contact radius. The relationship between these three parameters is derived using elastic theory. The discrepancy between the theoretical relationship and the experimental results is observed to increase as the deformation of the silicone rubber increases. Under smaller deformation conditions, the elastic theory shows good agreement with the experimental results, although infinite stress on the edge of the contact area is predicted in the theory, and time dependence and adhesion hysteresis are observed in all experiments. It is suggested that time dependence and adhesion hysteresis in contact are not induced by the deformation of the bulk of the silicone rubber, but are induced by surface effects. The result suggests that the applicability limit of the elastic theory must be carefully considered in the JKR analysis of point contact for polymers.